WATERTOWN — A cooperative of accountants, bankers, lawyers,
auctioneers, and management specialists helps local manufacturers come
back from the brink, says David A. Fiegel, president of the Upstate New
York Turnaround Management Association (UNYTMA).
Membership
in the organization costs $400 annually. People and companies join for
two purposes — to obtain new customers and to network with
professionals who perform similar or complementary services, Fiegel
explains.
For example, when M&T Bank realized
that one of its borrowers, Watertown–based specialty-paper
manufacturer, Knowlton Specialty Papers, Inc., was having trouble
repaying its loans, the bank recommended that fellow UNYTMA member JC
Jones & Associates, LLC — former Goulds Pumps, Inc. controller
Jeffrey Jones’ turnaround and restructuring company — tackle the
problem, Fiegel says.
Knowlton — the oldest,
continuously operating paper mill in the United States — was poised for
bankruptcy in 2003, explains Ronald Castor, a partner at JC Jones.
Several
factors contributed to the 200-year-old firm’s declining revenue,
Castor explains. First, in June 2002, an explosion in the manufacturing
plant killed one employee and destroyed 40 percent of the facility, he
says.
While the firm owned commercial-property
policies from two tier-one insurance carriers, one company refused to
reimburse Knowlton while the other limited its payout to a negligible
amount, Castor contends.
The blast caused a $2 million loss in annual revenue.
The
second factor contributing to Knowlton’s troubles was the stagnant
economy of the early 2000s and an industry-wide slump in paper sales.
Third,
two unnecessary, external plants burdened the company’s production.
Management was distracted from its core business while figuring out how
to use these facilities, Castor says.
JC Jones
employs 12 full-time and 11 part-time employees. While the firm is
based in the Rochester area, two turnaround-management specialists work
from their homes in the Syracuse area, Castor explains. They are John
J. Bellardini and Matthew C. Lumia.
Lumia, who
was actively involved in Knowlton’s turnaround, says he is currently
working with the management teams at about a dozen distressed companies
in Central New York. For confidentiality reasons, he won’t name the
firms, but says they are mainly in the manufacturing, distribution, and
construction industries.
Most referrals come from
banks interested in recouping their outstanding loans, Lumia says.
M&T selected three turnaround-management firms as candidates for
the Knowlton project and JC Jones won the bid, Castor says.
JC
Jones assigned two specialists, including Castor to the case. The firm
charges a daily fee for its services depending on project scope.
In
2003, JC Jones set out to fix issues with four items it saw as the
source of Knowlton’s problems — core operations, cash flow, personnel,
and customers.
JC Jones’s advice to Knowlton
included recommending it sell off-site locations, update its products
to eliminate variances, increase its prices, and lay off and replace
some employees.
Knowlton once employed 130, and
now has a 100-person staff. Knowlton returned to profitability in 2004
and 2005. In addition to his leadership at UNYTMA, Fiegel is also an
auctioneer and appraiser with Michael Fox International, Inc., where he
has experience with ailing businesses that, unlike Knowlton, do not
make a comeback.
Fiegel’s firm provided
auctioneering services during the shuttering of part or all of the
business operations at Carrier Corp., Rome Wire & Cable, and
Telergy, Inc., he says.
Fiegel says he helps a
defunct business sell off its manufacturing equipment to pay off some
of its debt. Often, he works on behalf of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court.
“There
are some businesses that have run their course,” Fiegel says of some of
the firms with which he has worked. He attributes the failure of some
manufacturers in Central New York to an increasingly unfriendly
business environment in the state due to higher taxes and more
stringent regulations.
“All these … increase overhead and the cost to comply with all the requirements,” he says.
During his years of dealing with businesses that have failed, Fiegel noticed similarities in many of the downfalls.
First,
businesses often succumb to “silver-spoon syndrome,” he says. Company
founders pass the family business to a second generation whose work
ethic and business savvy leaves something to be desired, Fiegel
contends.
“The parents are down in West Palm
Beach, and the kids tell them the business is doing great. Meanwhile
junior is out burning money … the business is crumbling around him,
while he’s out playing golf,” Fiegel quips.
The second mistake businesses make is failing to diversify their customer base, Fiegel argues.
With
increasing overseas competition, manufacturers cannot afford to base
their entire business on one or two clients who may choose to shop
elsewhere at any time.
“If your top five
customers [make up] 50 percent of your sales, you’re in trouble if they
go out of business [or change vendors],” Fiegel says. “Even if
everything is wonderful one day, when you lose that key account, it’s
enough to take you from profitability to losing money.”
The
third important pointer Fiegel has for manufacturers is the need to
update their products with the times, he says. Companies that ensure
that their products match or exceed competitors and identify changes
before they become the norm, have an advantage over firms that react to
what others are doing, Fiegel argues.
UNYTMA has
70 members and an annual budget of about $125,000. Nationally, the
Turnaround Management Association claims more than 7,000 members and
has an approximately $4 million annual budget, Fiegel says.